Letter from Ibbi-Suen to Puzur-Shulgi hoping for Ishbi-Erra’s downfall

The Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature

(Texts: All Artifacts, Color Coding, & Writings in Bold Type With Italics Inside Parenthesis, are Added by Editor R. Brown, not the Authors, Translators, or Publishers!)

(gods in bluemixed-breed demigods in teal…)

         Version A

Say to Puzur-Culgi (2 mss. have instead: Puzur-Numucda),

the governor of Kazallu: this is what Ibbi-Suen, your lord, says:

When I had chosen for you …… from among the troops, they were at your disposal, as governor of Kazallu.

But as in my own case, are not your troops (1 ms. has instead: your people) proof (?) of your importance?

Why have you sent me somebody saying:

Icbi-Erra has got his eyes upon me — so let me come to you when he falls upon me”?

How come you did not know how long it would take to make Icbi-Erra return to the mountain lands?

Why have you and Girbubu, the governor of Jirikal,

not confronted him with the troops which you had at hand?

How could you allow (?) him to restore (?) ……?

 (Enlil, King Anu‘s son & royal heir, Anu‘s Earth Colony Commander)

Today (?) Enlil loathes Sumer and has elevated to the shepherdship of the Land an ape

which has descended (2 mss. have instead: come forth) from those mountain lands.

Now Enlil has given kingship to an idiot, a seller of

(1 ms. has instead: who values) asafoetida (1 ms. has instead:

At this moment Enlil …… to somebody who sells asafoetida,

a peripatetic idiot) — to Icbi-Erra, who is not of Sumerian origin.

See, the assembly where the gods are and Sumer itself have been dispersed!

Father Enlil, whose words prevail (?), said:

3a - Nannar's Temple, Ziggourat, Home in Ur

      (city of Ur way below Nannar‘s ziggurat residence / mud brick-built mountain)

“Until the enemy has been expelled (?) from Urim (Ur),

Icbi-Erra, the man from Mari, will tear out Urim‘s foundations.

He will indeed measure out Sumer like grain.”

He has spoken just so.

Even though you were installed as governors of the various ……

the others will defect to Icbi-Erra, in accordance with Enlil‘s word.

Should you hand over your city to the enemy like your companions,

Icbi-Erra will not recognize you as his faithful and agreeable servant.

(1 ms. has instead: will Icbi-Erra) recognize you as his faithful and agreeable servant?

May it now be brought about (?) that good words should be restored and treason extinguished.

Let Icbi-Erra (?) participate in the harvest among the people there;

but you yourself, do not turn back (1 ms. has instead: do not harvest), and do not come to me!

His grasp should not get hold of the city!

This man from Mari, with the understanding of a dog, should not exercise lordship!

 (Earth Colony Commander Enlil, Anu, & Enki traverses the skies of Sumer in his sky-disc)

Now Enlil, my helper, has made the Martu (primitive earthlings under the giant alien god Martu)

rise from their mountain lands (1 ms. has instead:

Now Enlil has …… the Tidanum as …… from their mountain lands).

They will repel Elam and seize Icbi-Erra.

To regain the Land will indeed make our might known in all the foreign lands.

It is urgent! Do not be neglectful (1 ms. has instead: Do not all give up)!”


        Version B

unknown no. of lines missing

…… sent ……:

1 line missing

…… come (?).

…… they stood …….

How come you did not know …… to make …… return to the mountain lands?

…… of Jirikal, they had ……, they have not confronted him.

How could you allow him (?) to ……?

….. detests …….

After (?) he has elevated …… to the shepherdship of the Land.

…… has given kingship to …… asafoetida ……, who is …….

After …… has been dispersed,

3 lines missing

5c-unknown-goddess-utu-enlil (unidentified, Utu climbs ziggurat to visit Enlil in E-kur)
Enlil spoke thus: “…… will …….”

         1 line fragmentary

He (?) will defect to Icbi-Erra …….

So long as …… has indeed not been handed over to (?) the enemy,

will Icbi-Erra himself (?) recognize ……?

         You ……. …… he (?) destroyed (?) for you.

         1 line fragmentary

         …… he (?) overturns (?) there.

…… returning (?) ……. …… in my having …….

I (?) had in mind ……. …… was set there in prosperity.

…… is supreme over ……, after I (?) have made …… there.

I will seize him with my own hands …….

1 line fragmentary

unknown no. of lines missing